Overview

Listing ID:#20195742

Building SF:10,475

Parcel Size:0.80 Acres

Price:$1,350,000

Building PSF:$128.88

Property Type:Retail, Special Purpose

Date Available:Now

8.2% In-Place Yield + Strategic Land: Renovated, 100% Leased on 0.80 AC

2250 Pennsylvania Avenue is a fully leased, renovated 10,475 SF commercial building on a 0.80-acre infill parcel on Madison's Near East Isthmus. THE INCOME: Leased through December 31, 2031 with two 5-year options to 2041. In-place base rent of approximately $111,129 with 3.0% annual escalators on an NNN structure: the tenant pays real estate taxes, insurance, utilities, routine maintenance and CAM. The result is an approximately 8.2% yield on in-place rent at the $1,350,000 list price, rising to $114,463 (8.48%) at the July 2027 escalation. Luna Pet Resorts is a unique downtown pet boarding facility and the lease is corporately guaranteed by Wags N Whiskers, a multi-state operator of ~13 pet-care facilities across Wisconsin, Illinois, Indiana and Ohio. THE BUILDING: Ownership completed a ~$450,000 capital program in 2025-26 - new roof ($238K), full HVAC replacement ($138K), plus gutters, insulation, plumbing and stucco (~$74K) - and the parking lot was resealed and striped in June 2026. The next owner is not facing near-term roof or mechanical replacement. The grandfathered animal-services entitlement is effectively un-replicable under today's isthmus zoning (IL). The rear MG&E easement along the rail corridor may be used by the owner for parking and storage. The University of Wisconsin purchased the adjacent 2.7-acre parking-lot parcel at 2230 Pennsylvania and, concurrently, the nearby warehouse at 2180 Pennsylvania (recorded Dec 2025). The sale prices indicate land values around $1.3M per acre - at that basis, 2250's land alone supports roughly $1.0M of the list price. A proposed ~500-unit redevelopment of the former Hooper campus is advancing next door, and the Madison Public Market opens ~0.3 mi south in July 2026. Approximately 2 miles to Capitol Square, 2.7 miles to Dane County Regional Airport, with quick Hwy 30/151 access.

Building Details

Zoning:IL (Industrial-Limited)

Contact Listing Agent

WIlliam Butcher

(608) 345-1296

Important Disclaimer: Content for property listings on this website is provided by third parties. The party posting this listing is solely responsible for the accuracy of the information provided, including commissions. PropertyDrive makes no guarantee, warranty, or representation about the accuracy, timeliness or thoroughness and disclaims responsibility for the content of any property listing. PropertyDrive reserves the right to remove listings at any time.